LEGO 4194 Whitecap Bay is a Pirates of the Caribbean set valued at $275 for new and sealed sets, up 244% from an original retail price of $79.99. The set retired in November 2012 with annual appreciation averaging 6.93% since. Used copies are valued between $145 and $189 depending on condition. Secondary market prices for new and sealed sets typically fall between $250 and $300. As minifigure values rise while overall value eases, the market holds steady.

Whitecap Bay Value (New/Sealed)

This chart represents the current new/sealed value of the set Whitecap Bay since November 2016. Very high accuracy
LEGO 4194 Whitecap Bay is a Pirates of the Caribbean On Stranger Tides set released in 2011, containing 745 pieces and 6 minifigures. The build depicts the Whitecap Bay mermaid encounter and includes a lighthouse, a boathouse, rowboats, and a net-shooting cannon. Minifigures comprise Jack Sparrow, Philip, Scrum, Syrena, a pirate, and a mermaid. The set includes a large poster and can be combined with 4193 The London Escape to create a larger Port Royal scene.

A new Whitecap Bay sells for around $275 today, after averaging 6.9% growth a year since retirement. Give it five years and our forecast has it near $376. The average used price is $158 for those in good overall condition. The 6 included minifigs account for approximately 68% of the set's total value. New and sealed listings currently range from $283 to $421. The set was available for 19 months, from April 2011 to November 2012.
Collector and Investor Standing
Whitecap Bay of 2011 recreates the mermaid attack from On Stranger Tides, with its lighthouse and the mermaid Syrena rising from the water, from LEGO Pirates of the Caribbean. Mermaid figures are a treat in any LEGO collection, and together with the lighthouse they make this a set pirate collectors chase hard across the whole range.
82/100
Collector
Highly sought after
Mermaids and a lighthouse few fans pass up
80/100
Investor
A standout holding
Whitecap Bay trades often among interested members

For Sale (New/Sealed)

(US) NEW LEGO Pirates of the Caribbean Whitecap Bay 4194 , SEALED
BrickEconomy Choice
$299.99
(US) 4194 POTC Whitecap Bay (Item#1040) $349.99
+27.3%
(US) Disney Pirates of the Caribbean: Whitecap Bay (4194) SEALED Retired New $350.00
+27.3%
(US) Whitecap Bay from BrickLink seller premiumminifigs $233.99
-14.9%
(US) Whitecap Bay from BrickLink seller godfrey $250.00
-9.1%
(US) Whitecap Bay from BrickLink seller Bkillela $275.00
(US) NEW LEGO Pirates of the Caribbean Whitecap Bay 4194 , SEALED $359.99
+30.9%
(LV) Pirates of the Caribbean 4194: Whitecap Bay - Brand New Sealed (NISB) Rare $379.00
+37.8%
(DE) Pirates of the Caribbean Whitecap Bay 4194 new factory sealed original packaging $393.75
+43.2%
(DE) 4194 Whitecap Bay New Sealed MISB Pirates of the Caribbean 4194 4184 $425.32
+54.7%
(US) Pirates of the Caribbean 4194 Whitecap Bay (2011 Model) RETIRED SEALED $450.00
+63.6%
(US) #4194 PIRATES OF THE CARIBBEAN WHITECAP BAY RARE NEW SEALED $499.00
+81.5%
(KR) 4194 Disney Pirates of the Caribbean Whitecap Bay 746pcs Factory-Sealed $545.99
+98.5%
(KR) 4194 Disney Pirates of the Caribbean Whitecap Bay 746pcs Factory-Sealed $561.99
+104.4%
Picked for your region

Sales Distribution (Last 90 Days)

This chart shows the distribution of sales for the past three months of new/sealed 4194 Whitecap Bay.

Sale Trends

This chart shows the sales trends of new/sealed 4194 Whitecap Bay.

Market Momentum

Neutral
Since retirement, Whitecap Bay 4194 has held steady as listings thin and minifigure values rise. The set's value eases slightly, but member interest rises. It is the third-fastest-growing of the retired Pirates of the Caribbean On Stranger Tides sets over the past year.
DemandUpper half in Pirates of the Caribbean
Very high demand
12 months agoToday
SupplyTypical for Pirates of the Caribbean
Listings down 29% this month
12 months agoToday
Growth vs peers+14% typical for On Stranger Tides
+11% over the past year
12 months agoToday
Outlook:14% bearish·44% neutral·42% bullish
Why it's moving, signals and outlook

Compared with other On Stranger Tides sets

Whitecap Bay ranks last among the On Stranger Tides sets. The biggest factor is that it began at well over the retail price of the typical set above it.

#5 of 5
By growth since retail, +244%
+244%+800%
The weakest performer in the group.
$0.37 a piece
New and sealed value per piece
This set
$0.37
Typical
$0.74
About half the group's typical value per piece.
#1 of 5
Used value as a share of new, 57%
30%57%
Used copies keep the most of their new value in the group.
#2 of 5 retired
Wanted for each member who owns it
This set
Typical
About 25% above the rate of the group's retired sets.
All On Stranger Tides setsValueSince retail
4195 Queen Anne's Revenge$999+733%
4194 Whitecap Bay$275+244%
4193 The London Escape$268+436%
4192 Fountain of Youth$180+800%
4191 Captain's Cabin$70+483%

Sets in Pirates of the Caribbean / On Stranger Tides

4195 Queen Anne's Revenge

Year 2011
Pieces / Minifigs 1,097 / 10
Availability Retired
4195 LEGO Pirates of the Caribbean On Stranger Tides Queen Anne's Revenge
Retail $119.99
Value $999.30
Growth  +732.8%
Annual growth 10.8%

4193 The London Escape

Year 2011
Pieces / Minifigs 462 / 5
Availability Retired
4193 LEGO Pirates of the Caribbean On Stranger Tides The London Escape
Retail $49.99
Value $267.96
Growth  +436.0%
Annual growth 8.3%

4192 Fountain of Youth

Year 2011
Pieces / Minifigs 125 / 4
Availability Retired
4192 LEGO Pirates of the Caribbean On Stranger Tides Fountain of Youth
Retail $19.99
Value $180.00
Growth  +800.5%
Annual growth 9.0%

4191 Captain's Cabin

Year 2011
Pieces / Minifigs 94 / 3
Availability Retired
4191 LEGO Pirates of the Caribbean On Stranger Tides Captain's Cabin
Retail $11.99
Value $69.86
Growth  +482.7%
Annual growth 8.6%

Whitecap Bay Questions

How much is the Whitecap Bay set worth?

Today's value for a new, sealed copy of Whitecap Bay is $275. Sealed copies typically change hands for $250 to $300. Its value has eased 5% over the last 90 days. On the used market, expect to pay around $158.

Is LEGO 4194 Whitecap Bay retired?

Yes. Whitecap Bay retired in November 2012, having been in production for 19 months, about as long as the typical On Stranger Tides set. Collectors now buy it on the secondary market, from sellers on sites like eBay and BrickLink.

Has LEGO 4194 Whitecap Bay increased in value?

Yes, by a wide margin. Since it sold for $79.99 in shops, Whitecap Bay has risen 244% in value, about 6.9% a year. That is behind the On Stranger Tides average of 8.4% a year, so other sets in its group have grown faster.

How much could LEGO 4194 Whitecap Bay be worth in a year?

Our one-year forecast has Whitecap Bay at around $295 a year from now, about 7% more than today. The short-term market reading is neutral. Demand, supply and price show no clear direction. Forecasts are estimates, not guarantees.

What comes in LEGO 4194 Whitecap Bay?

Whitecap Bay has 745 pieces ($0.11 a piece at its retail price), and 6 minifigures: Captain Jack Sparrow, Gunner Zombie, Mermaid Syrena, Mermaid, Philip Swift and Scrum. Their combined value is about $187, about 68% of what the set is worth. Mermaid Syrena is the most valuable at $75. Mermaid Syrena, Mermaid and Philip Swift cannot be found in any other set.

Get a value badge
Show this set's value on your website or blog.
Captain Jack Sparrow and his band of pirates are lying in wait, plotting to capture one of the mysterious mermaids of Whitecap Bay. Hide inside the lighthouse, then use the searchlight to spot them in the murky depths below. Shoot the net from the boathouse cannon when they get close to shore! Beware of the whale oil barrels tipping near the open flames!

Includes 6 minifigures: Jack Sparrow, Philip, Scrum, Syrena, pirate and mermaid Features lighthouse, boathouse, rowboats, net-shooting cannon and working searchlight Includes flame elements, gold bricks and coins Use the cannon to launch the net!

Tip the whale oil barrel! Use the explode function to create chaos in the lighthouse! Searchlight really lights up! Row the rowboats with the oars!

Measures over 10” (25cm) tall and 12” (30cm) wide Rowboats measure over 4” (10cm) long and 1” (2cm) wide Includes free poster!
Description provided by LEGO©