Brickset
“This set is mighty good. The Y-wing is awfully narrow but the engines and body section look very realistic. The minifig is good, has a unique Biggs Darklighter helmet, but the control display sucks. This does have control sticks though, so it is realistic in that way. The... More cockpit is slim so the poor guy has to lie down to fly it. The Y-wing is cool, and looks realistic. The TIE Advanced is like any other TIE Advanced, it is thick, cool, sturdy, and well put together and designed. I am an Imperial pilot, thpugh, so I root for the stormies and TIE squadrons! A descent 9! Overpriced, though!”
Full review at brickset.com
BrickEconomy Member Review
“This set offers a large, detailed Y-Wing with rotating cannons, a functional cockpit, and an Astromech droid slot, alongside a realistic TIE Fighter with adjustable wings and an opening cockpit. While the build may feel a bit blocky, especially on the Y-Wing, and the landing gear requires manual adjustment, the set's overall design and included minifigures like Darth Vader make it a solid choice for Star Wars fans.”