LEGO 6712 Sheriff's Showdown is a vintage Western set from 1996 valued at $89 for new and sealed sets, up 2129% from an original retail price of $3.99. Annual appreciation has averaged 7.64% since release. On the used market, values range from $21 to $27 based on condition. Its market is holding steady for now, even with thinning listings.

Sheriff's Showdown Value (New/Sealed)

This chart represents the current new/sealed value of the set Sheriff's Showdown since December 2016. Very high accuracy
LEGO 6712 Sheriff’s Showdown is a Western Cowboys set released in 1996, containing 28 pieces and 2 minifigures. The vignette features a campfire, a brown barrel, a green bush, and the sheriff’s horse, with characters Black Bart and a Sheriff minifigure known regionally as Sheriff Wild Wyatt West or Sheriff Silver. The set was also marketed as “Rustler’s Retreat.”

Sheriff's Showdown has gained about 7.6% a year since it left store shelves, and a sealed copy now sits near $89. We forecast roughly 6% more over the next year. The average used price is $23 for those in good overall condition. New and sealed listings currently range from $99 to $110. The 2 included minifigs account for approximately 34% of the set's total value.
Collector and Investor Standing
The Western line gives collectors a Sheriff and Bandit face-off, the sort of simple cowboy scene that makes the theme easy to like. The pairing gives Sheriff's Showdown its particular appeal, while the many members who own it or want it give investors a solid reason to take notice.
74/100
Collector
Above the usual interest
Sheriff and Bandit make Western appealing
76/100
Investor
Firmer than most
Many members own or want this showdown

For Sale (New/Sealed)

(US) Vintage Lego System Sheriff's Showdown 6712 Wild West - Brand NEW & Sealed
BrickEconomy Choice
$89.99
(US) Sheriff's Showdown from BrickLink seller Bkillela $80.00
-10.0%
(CA) VINTAGE WESTERN 6712 SHERIFF'S SHOWDOWN SEALED (RETIRED) $98.30
+10.5%
(US) Western Cowboys Sheriffs Showdown 6712 26pcs Ages 5-10 Vintage 1997 $100.00
+12.5%
(NL) System 6712 Wild West Sheriff's Staredown 1996 New Sealed In Box $107.86
+21.3%
(US) Vintage Lego System Sheriff's Showdown 6712 Wild West - Brand NEW & Sealed $110.00
+23.7%
(US) Wild West Sheriffs Showdown 6712 NISB $110.00
+23.7%
(US) Wild West Sheriffs Showdown 6712 NISB $120.00
+35.0%
Picked for your region

Market Momentum

Neutral
Listings are thinning out and this set's value is climbing, but momentum is holding level for now.
DemandTop 25% in Western
Very high demand
12 months agoToday
SupplyTypical for Western
Listings down 20% this month
12 months agoToday
Growth vs peers+6% typical for Cowboys
+3% over the past year
12 months agoToday
Outlook:7% bearish·53% neutral·40% bullish
Why it's moving, signals and outlook

Sheriff's Showdown Minifigs

Sheriff's Showdown contains 2 minifigures.

Compared with other Cowboys sets

One thing stands out in Sheriff's Showdown's case. A lower starting price gave it less ground to make up than most sets below it.

#3 of 12
By growth since retail, +2,129%
+956%+2,319%
In the top quarter of the group.
$3.18 a piece
New and sealed value per piece
This set
$3.18
Typical
$2.10
About 50% above the group's typical value per piece.
#11 of 12
Used value as a share of new, 25%
21%61%
In the bottom quarter of the group.
#11 of 12 retired
Wanted for each member who owns it
This set
Typical
About half the rate of the group's retired sets.
Top sets by growthSince retail
16790 Bandit with Gun+2,319%
26716 Covered Wagon+2,238%
36712 Sheriff's Showdown+2,129%

Sets in Western / Cowboys

6769 Fort Legoredo

Theme / Subtheme Western / Cowboys
Year 1996
Pieces / Minifigs 687 / 10
Availability Retired
6769 Western Cowboys Fort Legoredo
Retail $84.99
Value $1,393.32
Growth  +1539.4%
Annual growth 7.3%

6765 Gold City Junction

Theme / Subtheme Western / Cowboys
Year 1996
Pieces / Minifigs 350 / 6
Availability Retired
6765 LEGO Western Cowboys Gold City Junction
Retail $49.99
Value $528.02
Growth  +956.3%
Annual growth 5.2%

6761 Bandit's Secret Hide-Out

Theme / Subtheme Western / Cowboys
Year 1996
Pieces / Minifigs 250 / 5
Availability Retired
6761 LEGO Western Cowboys Bandit's Secret Hide-Out
Retail $39.99
Value $538.53
Growth  +1246.7%
Annual growth 7.2%

6755 Sheriff's Lock-Up

Theme / Subtheme Western / Cowboys
Year 1996
Pieces / Minifigs 176 / 4
Availability Retired
6755 LEGO Western Cowboys Sheriff's Lock-Up
Retail $24.99
Value $298.70
Growth  +1095.3%
Annual growth 5.6%

6716 Covered Wagon

Theme / Subtheme Western / Cowboys
Year 1996
Pieces / Minifigs 64 / 1
Availability Retired
6716 LEGO Western Cowboys Covered Wagon
Retail $7.99
Value $186.81
Growth  +2238.0%
Annual growth 8.0%

Sheriff's Showdown Questions

What is the current value of LEGO 6712 Sheriff's Showdown?

Sealed in its box, Sheriff's Showdown is currently valued at $89. The value has risen 6% in the past 90 days. Used copies are worth about $23.

Is LEGO 6712 Sheriff's Showdown still available?

No. Sheriff's Showdown has been retired by LEGO. Collectors now buy it on the secondary market, from sellers on sites like eBay and BrickLink.

How has LEGO 6712 Sheriff's Showdown performed since its release?

Since it sold for $3.99 in shops, Sheriff's Showdown has risen 2,129% in value, or roughly 7.6% a year on average. That is a little ahead of the Cowboys average of 6.5% a year.

What is the one-year forecast for LEGO 6712 Sheriff's Showdown?

In twelve months, Sheriff's Showdown could be worth around $94, about 6% more than today. In the short term the market reads neutral. Signals from demand, supply and price are mixed. Like any forecast, this is an estimate.

What comes in LEGO 6712 Sheriff's Showdown?

Sheriff's Showdown has 28 pieces, or $0.14 per piece at retail, and 2 minifigures: Black Bart and Sheriff. Together the minifigures are worth about $30, about a third of the set's value, and Sheriff is the most valuable at $16.

Get a value badge
Show this set's value on your website or blog.
Rustler’s Retreat
From 5 years.
Description provided by LEGO©