Most Valuable LEGO Creator Sets

Worth $522 new and sealed, 4696 Blue Bucket is the most valuable LEGO Creator set today. The sets below span 2003 to 2010, and every one of them has retired. The middle set on the list is worth about $238. Sets from the 2000s make up nearly all of the list. Creator has covered two kinds of sets, loose brick buckets and boxes in its early years and 3 in 1 models since. Sealed buckets from the early 2000s are rare because nearly all of them were opened, which is why a plain box of bricks can be worth more than a model.

Below are the most valuable LEGO Creator sets on the secondary market today, ranked by their current value new and sealed.

Most valuable LEGO Creator set
4696 Blue Bucket $521.82

Largest set
3598 XXL 2000 Tube 2,000 pieces

Set with the most minifigures
31142 Space Roller Coaster 6 minifigures

Most owned set
31120 Medieval Castle


	4696 Blue Bucket Theme / Subtheme Creator / Bucket Year 2004 Pieces 400 Availability Retired It comes packaged in a blue storage bucket with a blue 2x2-stud lid and was marketed as an “extra value” bucket (200 + 200 pieces). Buy this set at Amazon BrickLink	Retail $8.50 Value $521.82 Growth +6039.1% Annual growth 11.6% I own this set I want this set

	4997 Transport Ferry Theme / Subtheme Creator / 3 in 1 Year 2008 Pieces 1,279 Availability Retired It consists of a ferry with a working back ramp, a car with a trailer, and instructions to rebuild into a transport hovercraft or a cargo plane. Buy this set at Amazon eBay BrickLink	Retail $69.99 Value $311.60 Growth +345.2% Annual growth 9.2% I own this set I want this set

	4679-2 Bricks and Creations Theme Creator Year 2004 Pieces 1,531 Availability Retired Distributed exclusively through Toys “R” Us, it was packaged as a large storage bucket focused on open-ended building. Buy this set at BrickLink	Retail $19.99 Value $308.33 Growth +1442.4% Annual growth 6.2% I own this set I want this set

	4894 Mythical Creatures Theme Creator Year 2006 Pieces 588 Availability Retired It features 8 models of mythical creatures, including a dragon and a troll, and introduces the Light Brick. Buy this set at Amazon eBay	Retail $29.99 Value $281.17 Growth +837.5% Annual growth 5.5% I own this set I want this set

	4421 Big LEGO Box 1000 Theme Creator Year 2005 Pieces 1,000 Availability Retired It is a bulk assortment intended for open-ended building and includes a large idea book with model suggestions. Buy this set at Amazon BrickLink	Retail $19.99 Value $276.47 Growth +1283.0% Annual growth 10.0% I own this set I want this set

	3598 XXL 2000 Tube Theme / Subtheme Creator / Bucket Year 2005 Pieces 2,000 Availability Retired It was a regional exclusive in Denmark and was packaged in a cardboard cylinder. The assortment focuses on basic bricks and slopes in multiple colors intended for open-ended building. Buy this set at BrickLink	Retail $12.99 Value $271.60 Growth +1990.8% Annual growth 8.0% I own this set I want this set

	4954 Model Town House Theme / Subtheme Creator / 3 in 1 Year 2007 Pieces 1,174 Availability Retired It features 3 model options, a town house with a functional garage, interior details, and options for customization. The featured house contains a garage that opens and closes, and a blue car. Buy this set at eBay BrickLink	Retail $69.99 Value $253.82 Growth +262.7% Annual growth 5.8% I own this set I want this set

	4957 Ferris Wheel Theme / Subtheme Creator / 3 in 1 Year 2007 Pieces 1,063 Availability Retired It includes a Ferris Wheel that rotates using a motor and battery box, a ticket booth, micro people and scenery. Buy this set at Amazon eBay BrickLink	Retail $69.99 Value $245.01 Growth +250.1% Annual growth 4.4% I own this set I want this set

	4518 Creator Value Pack Theme Creator Year 2004 Pieces 800 Availability Retired It consists of the instruction booklet for set 4410, functioning as a supplementary release linked to that model. Buy this set at eBay	Retail $9.99 Value $243.28 Growth +2335.2% Annual growth 9.1% I own this set I want this set

	4958 Monster Dino Theme / Subtheme Creator / 3 in 1 Year 2007 Pieces 792 Availability Retired It features a Monster Dino with glow-in-the-dark spine, moving arms, and mouth. Can be rebuilt into a crawling spider or moving crocodile. The set is motorized. Buy this set at eBay BrickLink	Retail $89.99 Value $241.47 Growth +168.3% Annual growth 4.9% I own this set I want this set

	4919 LEGO Deluxe Theme / Subtheme Creator / Bucket Year 2005 Pieces 1,500 Availability Retired Packaged in a blue tub with a clip-on lid, it comprises a large assortment of basic bricks in black, blue, green, orange, red, white, and yellow. Buy this set at eBay BrickLink	Retail $19.99 Value $238.21 Growth +1091.6% Annual growth 9.2% I own this set I want this set

	6753 Highway Transport Theme / Subtheme Creator / 3 in 1 Year 2009 Pieces 1,294 Availability Retired It features a functioning steering mechanism, a trailer that lowers for loading and unloading vehicles, and instructions to rebuild into a tow truck or mobile crane. Buy this set at eBay BrickLink	Retail $89.99 Value $201.51 Growth +123.9% Annual growth 5.2% I own this set I want this set

	4956 House Theme / Subtheme Creator / 3 in 1 Year 2007 Pieces 731 Availability Retired It consists of parts for three house models with garage, driveway, fence, roofs, walls, doors, windows, trees, gardens. Provides building instructions for three models. Buy this set at eBay BrickLink	Retail $49.99 Value $199.52 Growth +299.1% Annual growth 4.8% I own this set I want this set

	5369 Creator Tub Theme / Subtheme Creator / Bucket Year 2005 Pieces 700 Availability Retired It comes in a red storage tub with a lid molded with six studs. The assortment includes basic bricks in black, blue, green, orange, red, white, and yellow, spanning common sizes from 1x1 to 2x8. Buy this set at ebay BrickLink	Retail $19.99 Value $190.00 Growth +850.5% Annual growth 7.4% I own this set I want this set

	4886 Building Bonanza Theme / Subtheme Creator / Designer Set Year 2004 Pieces 667 Availability Retired It was also called just Buildings and was a 3-in-1 set that could rebuild from one of 2 houses into a windmill or a lighthouse. Buy this set at eBay BrickLink	Retail $39.99 Value $187.09 Growth +367.8% Annual growth 7.3% I own this set I want this set

	4888 Underwater Exploration Theme / Subtheme Creator / Designer Set Year 2005 Pieces 623 Availability Retired It features four main submarine models, additional underwater exploration vehicles, and an Idea Book with instructions for 11 models and concepts for 26 more. Building difficulty levels include Quick Build, Experienced Build, and Advanced Build. Buy this set at Amazon ebay BrickLink	Retail $39.99 Value $177.57 Growth +344.0% Annual growth 5.1% I own this set I want this set

	4508 Titan XP Theme / Subtheme Creator / Designer Set Year 2004 Pieces 784 Availability Retired It features new joints for realistic positioning and includes an Idea Book for building alternative models, such as a transforming robot. Buy this set at eBay BrickLink	Retail $49.99 Value $173.20 Growth +246.5% Annual growth 5.8% I own this set I want this set

	4048 Mechs Theme / Subtheme Creator / Designer Set Year 2003 Pieces 554 Availability Retired This value pack bundles sets 4097 Mini Robots and 4099 Robobots from the Designer Set subtheme. Together they build four robot models in red, green, yellow, and blue color schemes. Buy this set at eBay BrickLink	Retail $29.99 Value $167.67 Growth +459.1% Annual growth 3.7% I own this set I want this set

	4955 Big Rig Theme / Subtheme Creator / 3 in 1 Year 2007 Pieces 550 Availability Retired It consists of a Big Rig with heavy-duty tires, adjustable mirrors, opening doors, and a visible engine. Can be rebuilt into a go-cart or convertible with functional doors. Buy this set at Amazon eBay BrickLink	Retail $29.99 Value $166.28 Growth +454.5% Annual growth 6.3% I own this set I want this set

	5892 Sonic Boom Theme / Subtheme Creator / 3 in 1 Year 2010 Pieces 539 Availability Retired It features a jet with movable wing flaps, tail fins, and landing gear, and includes a light-up function. Can be rebuilt into a dual propeller plane or boat. Buy this set at eBay BrickLink	Retail $59.99 Value $155.63 Growth +159.4% Annual growth 4.0% I own this set I want this set

Most Valuable LEGO Creator Sets

See even more with a free account...