Most Valuable LEGO Pirates Sets

The most valuable LEGO Pirates set today is 6286 Skull's Eye Schooner, worth $5,324 new and sealed. This list covers sets released between 1989 and 2010, and every one of them has retired. The middle set on the list is worth about $1,466. Sets from the 1990s make up about 55% of the list. The big ships and forts carry the most value in Pirates, such as the 1989 Black Seas Barracuda and Eldorado Fortress. LEGO reissued the Black Seas Barracuda in 2002, and that version is worth a great deal too.

Below are the most valuable LEGO Pirates sets on the secondary market today, ranked by their current value new and sealed.

Most valuable LEGO Pirates set
6286 Skull's Eye Schooner $5,324.37

Highest growth set
1696 Pirate Lookout +19753.77%

Largest set
10210 Imperial Flagship 1,664 pieces

Set with the most minifigures
40158 Pirates Chess Set 20 minifigures

Most owned set
6270 Forbidden Island


	6286 Skull's Eye Schooner Theme Pirates Year 1993 Pieces / Minifigs 912 / 9 Availability Retired It builds a large three-masted pirate ship with detailed rigging and deck elements, plus a rowboat and a shark. Buy this set at eBay BrickLink	Retail $126.50 Value $5,324.37 Growth +4109.0% Annual growth 8.2% I own this set I want this set

	6285 Black Seas Barracuda Theme Pirates Year 1989 Pieces / Minifigs 909 / 8 Availability Retired It features a pirate ship with two masts, four cannons, cargo bays, a fold-down captain's quarters, and eight minifigures, including Captain Redbeard, pirates, and a soldier. Buy this set at Amazon eBay BrickLink	Retail $109.99 Value $3,871.21 Growth +3419.6% Annual growth 7.8% I own this set I want this set

	6276 Eldorado Fortress Theme Pirates Year 1989 Pieces / Minifigs 506 / 8 Availability Retired It consists of the Eldorado Fortress model, island treasures, and characters including Governor Broadside and pirate minifigures. Buy this set at ebay BrickLink	Retail $59.99 Value $2,466.67 Growth +4011.8% Annual growth 7.4% I own this set I want this set

	10040 Black Seas Barracuda Theme Pirates Year 2002 Pieces / Minifigs 906 / 8 Availability Retired The set, part of the Legends collection, a re-release of the original Black Seas Barracuda but contains a few pieces more than the first set. Buy this set at Amazon eBay BrickLink	Retail $89.99 Value $2,400.61 Growth +2567.6% Annual growth 8.3% I own this set I want this set

	6277 Imperial Trading Post Theme / Subtheme Pirates / Imperial Guards Year 1992 Pieces / Minifigs 608 / 9 Availability Retired It includes a trading post with several cannons, merchant ship, dock and three buildings, a row boat and a ship with two sails and two Imperial Guard Minifigures, one Imperial Officer and Admiral Woodhouse and a pirate and a Gonzo Goldbar pirate minifigure. Buy this set at eBay BrickLink	Retail $84.99 Value $2,144.96 Growth +2423.8% Annual growth 6.9% I own this set I want this set

	6274 Caribbean Clipper Theme Pirates Year 1989 Pieces / Minifigs 378 / 4 Availability Retired It includes a two-masted sailing ship named the Sea Hawk and features the leader of the Imperial Soldiers, Governor Broadside as well as 3 other minifigures. Buy this set at Amazon eBay BrickLink	Retail $54.00 Value $2,015.25 Growth +3631.9% Annual growth 7.8% I own this set I want this set

	6273 Rock Island Refuge Theme Pirates Year 1991 Pieces / Minifigs 381 / 7 Availability Retired It includes a large pirate hideout built upon a raised baseplate with a treasure cave, a pirate raft, a sailing boat belonging to the Imperial Soldiers, five pirates, two imperial soldier minifigures plus a shark and monkey. Buy this set at eBay BrickLink	Retail $66.00 Value $1,866.34 Growth +2727.8% Annual growth 8.0% I own this set I want this set

	6289 Red Beard Runner Theme Pirates Year 1996 Pieces / Minifigs 703 / 7 Availability Retired It includes a two-masted pirate ship with a semi-collapsing foremast, a dinghy and seven pirate minifigures, including Jake the Snake Blake, Black Jack Hawkins and Captain Redbeard. Buy this set at eBay BrickLink	Retail $99.00 Value $1,721.35 Growth +1638.7% Annual growth 6.7% I own this set I want this set

	6281 Pirates Perilous Pitfall Theme Pirates Year 1997 Pieces / Minifigs 395 / 6 Availability Retired Included minifigures are three Pirates and two Imperial Armada Conquistadores, a Conquistador skeleton and a crocodile. Buy this set at eBay	Retail $73.00 Value $1,633.43 Growth +2137.6% Annual growth 9.1% I own this set I want this set

	10210 Imperial Flagship Theme Pirates Year 2010 Pieces / Minifigs 1,664 / 9 Availability Retired In addition to the historical Imperial faction three-masted sailing ship, the set's minifigures include the ship’s captain, his daughter, a pirate captain prisoner with shackles, the ship’s cook, a lieutenant, and 4 soldiers. Buy this set at Amazon eBay BrickLink	Retail $179.99 Value $1,482.66 Growth +723.7% Annual growth 7.7% I own this set I want this set

	6250 Cross Bone Clipper Theme Pirates Year 1997 Pieces / Minifigs 154 / 3 Availability Retired It includes a one-masted pirate ship with a cannon and three pirates with one of them being Captain Redbeard the other two pirates were named Diver Dan and Scuba Sandy. Buy this set at eBay BrickLink	Retail $32.99 Value $1,465.94 Growth +4343.6% Annual growth 9.4% I own this set I want this set

	1788 Treasure Chest Theme Pirates Year 1995 Pieces / Minifigs 159 / 4 Availability Retired A United States–exclusive release also known as Pirate's Chest, it includes King Kahuka, Captain Ironhook, Gonzo Goldbar, and an Islander. Buy this set at ebay BrickLink	Retail $21.99 Value $1,406.04 Growth +6294.0% Annual growth 14.4% I own this set I want this set

	6291 Armada Flagship Theme Pirates Year 2001 Pieces / Minifigs 280 / 3 Availability Retired It was also know as "Santa Cruz" and "Spanish Ship" and includes 3 Imperial Armada minifigures, modeled after a Spaniard ship, first released in 1996. Buy this set at eBay BrickLink	Retail $49.99 Value $1,364.96 Growth +2630.5% Annual growth 10.0% I own this set I want this set

	6271 Imperial Flagship Theme / Subtheme Pirates / Imperial Guards Year 1992 Pieces / Minifigs 317 / 4 Availability Retired It consists of a one-masted ship with a functional rudder mechanism, two cannons, a compass, a treasure chest, and minifigures of Admiral Woodhouse, an officer, a soldier , and a deckhand. Buy this set at eBay BrickLink	Retail $49.99 Value $1,333.58 Growth +2567.7% Annual growth 7.4% I own this set I want this set

	6278 Enchanted Island Theme / Subtheme Pirates / Islanders Year 1994 Pieces / Minifigs 428 / 7 Availability Retired The set was also called "Indigo Island". It includes seven minifigures which are two pirates (one is Captain Ironhook) and five islanders. Buy this set at eBay BrickLink	Retail $66.00 Value $1,256.96 Growth +1804.5% Annual growth 7.4% I own this set I want this set

	6268 Renegade Runner Theme Pirates Year 1993 Pieces / Minifigs 178 / 4 Availability Retired It contains a one-masted pirate ship and four pirates including Captain IronHook, First Mate Rummy and two pirates. It was also called "Sea Vulture". Buy this set at Amazon eBay BrickLink	Retail $39.75 Value $1,190.66 Growth +2895.4% Annual growth 7.1% I own this set I want this set

	6290 Red Beard Runner Theme Pirates Year 2001 Pieces / Minifigs 698 / 7 Availability Retired It is a re-release of 6289 Red Beard Runner from 1996 and includes a a two-masted pirate ship, a dinghy and seven pirate minifigures, including Captain Redbeard, Black Jack Hawkins and Jake the Snake Blake. Buy this set at eBay BrickLink	Retail $99.99 Value $1,144.08 Growth +1044.2% Annual growth 8.4% I own this set I want this set

	6292 Enchanted Island Theme / Subtheme Pirates / Islanders Year 2001 Pieces / Minifigs 419 / 7 Availability Retired It consists of an island with a river, tree-like structures, a tower, seven minifigures (5 Islanders, 2 pirates), various weapons, animals, and treasure elements. This set is a reissue of the 1994 set 6278 Enchanted Island. Buy this set at Amazon eBay BrickLink	Retail $69.99 Value $1,135.22 Growth +1522.0% Annual growth 9.2% I own this set I want this set

	6270 Forbidden Island Theme Pirates Year 1989 Pieces / Minifigs 182 / 4 Availability Retired It includes a pirate hideout, a rope bridge, a row boat, three pirate minifigures including Captain Redbeard and First Mate Rummey, an Imperial Soldier, a monkey, a parrot and a shark. Buy this set at Amazon eBay BrickLink	Retail $37.49 Value $979.47 Growth +2512.6% Annual growth 5.4% I own this set I want this set

	6279 Skull Island Theme Pirates Year 1995 Pieces / Minifigs 378 / 6 Availability Retired It includes a pirate outpost with a large cave with a building, two a row boats, four pirates, ad two Imperial Soldiers, an officer and a soldier. Buy this set at Amazon eBay BrickLink	Retail $53.00 Value $964.41 Growth +1719.6% Annual growth 8.3% I own this set I want this set

Most Valuable LEGO Pirates Sets

See even more with a free account...