LEGO 40423 Halloween Hayride is a Seasonal set valued at $22 for new and sealed sets, up 70% from an original retail price of $12.99. The set retired in October 2021 with annual appreciation averaging 7.45% since. On the used market, values range from $20 to $25 based on condition. Secondary market prices for new and sealed sets typically fall between $21 and $38. Lately, the set's value has eased as it grows slower than similar retired sets and member interest cools.

Halloween Hayride Value (New/Sealed)

This chart represents the current new/sealed value of the set Halloween Hayride since October 2021. Very high accuracy
LEGO 40423 Halloween Hayride is a Seasonal Halloween set released in 2020, containing 148 pieces and 3 minifigures. The build depicts a haunted hayride with a vintage tractor pulling a hay cart and a Halloween-themed entrance arch. It includes two costumed minifigures and a skeleton figure, along with festive Halloween decorations and accessories.

Sealed copies of Halloween Hayride go for about $22 today. Since it retired, the set has grown roughly 7.4% a year, and our forecast puts it near $23 by this time next year. The average used price is $21 for those in good overall condition. New and sealed listings currently range from $26 to $42. The 3 included minifigs account for approximately 48% of the set's total value. The set was available for 14 months, from August 2020 to October 2021.
Collector and Investor Standing
Strong with collectors and weak with investors, Halloween Hayride is a set bought to keep.
72/100
Collector
Drawing strong interest
Has minifigures found in no other set
47/100
Investor
Softer than most
Market activity is cooling

For Sale (New/Sealed)

(CA) Seasonal: Halloween Hayride Set (40423) Brand New & Factory Sealed $18.58
-15.7%
(DE) 40423 Halloween Tractor Ride BNIB $21.24
-3.7%
(DE) Seasonal - 40423 Halloween tractor ride Halloween Hayride - new & original packaging $22.37
+1.5%
(US) Halloween Hayride from BrickLink seller briklovrz $23.68
+7.4%
(US) Halloween Hayride from BrickLink seller briklovrz $23.68
+7.4%
(DE) Halloween Tractor Ride 40423 NEW & Original Packaging $26.74
+21.3%
(US) Halloween Hayride from BrickLink seller SMBMW332is $35.14
+59.4%
(US) Iconic: Halloween Hayride (40423) $37.99
+72.3%
(US) Iconic: Halloween Hayride (40423) ~NEW / FACTORY SEALED~ $37.99
+72.3%
(US) Halloween Hayride 40423 Hay Ride Retired Set BRAND NEW FACTORY SEALED BOX $38.00
+72.3%
(US) Iconic: Halloween Hayride (40423) BNIB Perfect for Halloween $44.99
+104.0%
(CA) Seasonal: Halloween Hayride Set (40423) Brand New & Factory Sealed $45.55
+106.6%
(US) New Sealed Retired Lego #40423 Halloween Hayride 148pcs Tractor Fall Festival $53.99
+144.9%
(US) Halloween Hayride 40423 Hay Ride Retired Set BRAND NEW FACTORY SEALED BOX $53.99
+144.9%
(US) 40423 Halloween Hayride Set Brand New Factory Sealed $54.97
+149.3%
Picked for your region

Sales Distribution (Last 90 Days)

This chart shows the distribution of sales for the past three months of new/sealed 40423 Halloween Hayride.

Sale Trends

This chart shows the sales trends of new/sealed 40423 Halloween Hayride.

Market Momentum

Bearish
40423 Halloween Hayride has eased in value over the last three months. This slowdown follows a year where it lagged behind similar retired Seasonal sets, while member interest continues to cool.
DemandUpper half in Seasonal
Very high demand but falling
12 months agoToday
SupplyTypical for Seasonal
Listings down 25% this month
12 months agoToday
Growth vs peers+0% typical for Halloween
-33% over the past year
12 months agoToday
Outlook:70% bearish·10% neutral·20% bullish
Why it's moving, signals and outlook

Halloween Hayride Minifigs

Halloween Hayride contains 3 minifigures. Two of the minifigures are exclusive to this set.

Compared with other Halloween sets

Given that the sets at the top of the group retired years earlier and that Halloween Hayride's value fell further than that of similar sets over the past year, it is no surprise that it ranks among the weakest Halloween sets.

#16 of 18
By growth since retail, +70%
+33%+526%
In the bottom quarter of the group.
$0.15 a piece
New and sealed value per piece
This set
$0.15
Typical
$0.16
Close to the group's typical value per piece.
#1 of 17
Used value as a share of new, 94%
26%94%
Used copies keep the most of their new value in the group.
#11 of 18 retired
Wanted for each member who owns it
This set
Typical
Close to the rate of the group's retired sets.
Top sets by growthSince retail
1850936 Halloween Set+526%
240122 Trick or Treat Halloween Set+358%
340260 Halloween Haunt+300%
1640423 Halloween Hayride+70%

Sets in Seasonal / Halloween

40825 Halloween Wreath

Theme / Subtheme Seasonal / Halloween
Year 2025
Pieces 617
Availability Retail
40825 LEGO Halloween Wreath
Retail $39.99
Available at retail

40570 Cat and Mouse

Theme / Subtheme Seasonal / Halloween
Year 2022
Pieces 328
Availability Retired
40570 LEGO Halloween Cat and Mouse
Retail $12.99
Value $34.15
Growth  +162.9%
Annual growth 30.4%

40872 Halloween Pumpkin Lantern

Theme / Subtheme Seasonal / Halloween
Year 2026
Pieces / Minifigs 323 / 1
Availability Retail
40872 LEGO Halloween Pumpkin Lantern
Retail $29.99
Available at retail

40497 Halloween Owl

Theme / Subtheme Seasonal / Halloween
Year 2021
Pieces 228
Availability Retired
40497 LEGO Halloween Owl
Retail $14.99
Value $30.00
Growth  +100.1%
Annual growth 11.2%

40721 Halloween Barn

Theme / Subtheme Seasonal / Halloween
Year 2024
Pieces / Minifigs 205 / 1
Availability Retired
40721 LEGO Halloween Barn
Retail $14.99
Value $19.98
Growth  +33.3%

40883 Halloween Skull Candle

Theme / Subtheme Seasonal / Halloween
Year 2026
Pieces 204
Availability Retail
40883 LEGO Halloween Skull Candle
Retail $19.99
Available at retail

40822 Jack-O'-Lantern Pickup Truck

Theme / Subtheme Seasonal / Halloween
Year 2025
Pieces / Minifigs 177 / 1
Availability Retail (Retiring soon)
40822 LEGO Halloween Jack-O'-Lantern Pickup Truck
Retail $14.99
Available at retail
Retiring soon

40090 Halloween Bat

Theme / Subtheme Seasonal / Halloween
Year 2014
Pieces 156
Availability Retired
40090 LEGO Halloween Bat
Retail $9.99
Value $27.77
Growth  +178.0%
Annual growth 4.8%

40203 Vampire and Bat

Theme / Subtheme Seasonal / Halloween
Year 2016
Pieces 150
Availability Retired
40203 LEGO Halloween Vampire and Bat
Retail $9.99
Value $17.99
Growth  +80.1%
Annual growth 3.9%

40260 Halloween Haunt

Theme / Subtheme Seasonal / Halloween
Year 2017
Pieces / Minifigs 145 / 2
Availability Retired
40260 LEGO Halloween Haunt
Retail $9.99
Value $39.99
Growth  +300.3%
Annual growth 7.9%

40122 Trick or Treat Halloween Set

Theme / Subtheme Seasonal / Halloween
Year 2015
Pieces / Minifigs 133 / 2
Availability Retired
40122 LEGO Trick or Treat Halloween Set
Retail $9.99
Value $45.71
Growth  +357.6%
Annual growth 6.7%

40493 Spider & Haunted House

Theme / Subtheme Seasonal / Halloween
Year 2021
Pieces 132
Availability Retired
40493 LEGO Halloween Spider & Haunted House
Retail $9.99
Value $27.99
Growth  +180.2%
Annual growth 10.8%

854049 Pumpkin & Bat Duo

Theme / Subtheme Seasonal / Halloween
Year 2020
Pieces 131
Availability Retired
854049 LEGO Halloween Pumpkin & Bat Duo
Retail $9.99
Value $19.63
Growth  +96.5%
Annual growth 7.0%

40020 Halloween Set

Theme / Subtheme Seasonal / Halloween
Year 2011
Pieces 71
Availability Retired
40020 LEGO Halloween Set
Retail $4.99
Value $11.91
Growth  +138.7%
Annual growth 6.5%

40032 Witch

Theme / Subtheme Seasonal / Halloween
Year 2012
Pieces 71
Availability Retired
40032 LEGO Halloween Witch
Retail $4.99
Value $7.86
Growth  +57.5%
Annual growth 2.0%

40021 Spiders Set

Theme / Subtheme Seasonal / Halloween
Year 2011
Pieces 54
Availability Retired
40021 LEGO Halloween Spiders Set
Retail $4.99
Value $8.50
Growth  +70.3%
Annual growth 3.1%

40055 Halloween Pumpkin

Theme / Subtheme Seasonal / Halloween
Year 2013
Pieces 52
Availability Retired
40055 LEGO Halloween Pumpkin
Retail $4.99
Value $15.41
Growth  +208.8%
Annual growth 9.8%

40014 Halloween Bat

Theme / Subtheme Seasonal / Halloween
Year 2010
Pieces 25
Availability Retired
40014 LEGO Halloween Bat
Retail $1.99
Value $6.53
Growth  +228.1%
Annual growth 5.5%

40012 Halloween Pumpkin

Theme / Subtheme Seasonal / Halloween
Year 2010
Pieces 18
Availability Retired
40012 LEGO Halloween Pumpkin
Retail $1.99
Value $6.58
Growth  +230.7%
Annual growth 3.7%

40013 Halloween Ghost

Theme / Subtheme Seasonal / Halloween
Year 2010
Pieces 18
Availability Retired
40013 LEGO Halloween Ghost
Retail $1.99
Value $6.37
Growth  +220.1%
Annual growth 3.6%

850936 Halloween Set

Theme / Subtheme Seasonal / Halloween
Year 2014
Pieces / Minifigs 11 / 1
Availability Retired
850936 LEGO Halloween Set
Retail $7.99
Value $49.99
Growth  +525.7%
Annual growth 9.2%

Halloween Hayride Questions

What is LEGO 40423 Halloween Hayride worth?

Sealed in its box, Halloween Hayride is valued at $22, with most sales landing between $21 and $38. Used copies are worth about $21.

When did LEGO 40423 Halloween Hayride retire?

LEGO retired Halloween Hayride in October 2021 after 14 months on store shelves, 6 months longer than the typical Halloween set. Sealed copies are now found only on the secondary market, so the price follows what collectors will pay.

How much has LEGO 40423 Halloween Hayride gone up in value?

Halloween Hayride has gained 70% on its original retail price of $12.99, or roughly 7.4% a year on average. That beats the Halloween average of 5.3% a year by a clear margin.

What will LEGO 40423 Halloween Hayride be worth next year?

BrickEconomy's forecast puts Halloween Hayride near $23 in twelve months, about 2% more than today. That is the view for the year ahead. In the short term the market reads bearish. On balance, demand, supply and price point down. This is an estimate and markets can change.

How many pieces and minifigures are in LEGO 40423 Halloween Hayride?

The set contains 148 pieces, about $0.09 each at retail, with 3 minifigures: Skeleton, Girl and Tractor Driver. Together the minifigures are worth about $11, about half of the set's value, and Tractor Driver is the most valuable at $4.76. Girl and Tractor Driver are exclusive to this set.

Get a value badge
Show this set's value on your website or blog.
Have fun at the Halloween Hayride (40423) with this awesome LEGO® Iconic building toy for kids. Youngsters can create a festive scene including a buildable entrance arch, vintage tractor, hay cart and lots of decorative details. The set features 2 minifigures with Halloween costume decoration and a skeleton figure for creative role play. An awesome gift idea for ages 7 and up, it also makes a fun, little display piece at a Halloween party.

Get in the festive mood with this LEGO® Iconic Halloween Hayride playset for kids, featuring a buildable entrance arch, vintage tractor, hay cart, smiling skeleton figure and fun Halloween decorations and accessories.
Description provided by LEGO©